Just finished residency, my case log for 4 years (did not count intern year)
2748 cases, even more proceedure codes, many of those cases were multi-extremity cases.
I DID NOT log near everything, like traction pins, all reductions, lots of I+D's. Particularly my 6 months of peds in the summer, when I had usually 5-7 and upwards of 15 reductions a night at times, every 4th night.
We were VERY busy. As chiefs, we operated every day of the week during the normal work week, 3-6 cases a day 5 days a week, not including call. Trauma work intermingled with private elective cases, the best of both worlds. Often independently, running our own rooms with attending oversight. Very limited clinic. Our program could use more residents.
Every place is different, and I do not think you can compare just numbers. Some places you are not doing a lot of operating because of the fellows or the attending you are working with. Some places you are operating independently as a second year due to lack of attending coverage. While this may seem good and fun, having some direction is beneficial.