In September of this year I participated in an unofficial survey of 35 post-hand fellowship graduates from 2005 through 2008. Sliding scale questions pertained to office schedules, automony, range of surgery cases, work loads, facility amenities, in-service conferences, educational resources, etc.
Participants who completed the survey ranked Indiana Hand, Cincinnati, and Phildelphia Hand tied for first place. Both Duke and San Antonio (my match) were ranked as being a close second; then with Mass General, Baltimore, and Brown Univ. coming in an extremely close third.
My opinion is that you can't go wrong with any of these premier programs. Just request an interview (especially with the 2 excellent Midwest programs and of course San Antonio), and you'll come away with a sense of the group's history, the research, educational training, camaraderie amoung the partners, what the city offers, etc. with that particular group. For those ortho residents with youngsters, San I know that Cincinnati has a very nice aquarium and I think that Indianapolis has the world's largest Children's Museum.